New YouTube video reviewing the Younger Dryas impact debate


This will be a multi-parter that takes us from the original Firestone et al. publication in 2007 right through to the very latest papers...

Comments

  1. AnonymousDecember 10, 2019 at 5:04 AM

    This is very interesting. As a farmer I wonder if there was any agriculture culture before this recent warm period? Because agriculture needs a steady and predictable klimat, year after year...And the figures from climate and temperature before YD seem to have been to much up and down to give humans a possibility to agriculture. Only maybe in some places where the climate was steady. So people must have been hunters and gathers...
    Next problem must be all that filling material in places like Köbekli tepe. That can not been done by the people! I must be some other explanations.

    Thomas Gunnarson
    tg.edared@gmail. com

    ReplyDelete
  2. Prehistory DecodedDecember 10, 2019 at 10:17 AM

    There are research papers that suggest exactly this - that climate was too unstable to develop agriculture over the last ice age. Like you, I'm not sure I buy it - there would have been regions near the equator or in the southern hemisphere where climate was sufficiently stable.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Debunking YouTube's archaeoastronomy skeptics

Image
                                    Image from Scijinks.gov Some YouTube commentators, like Milo Rossi of MiniMinuteman and Stefan Milo, have made ignorant comments about the astronomical interpretation of Gobekli Tepe and Pillar 43. Below, I make the scientific case for this interpretation. Q: What is science? A: Science attempts to create consistent models of reality. Q: What is a good model? A: One that has a lot of explaining power relative to its inputs. This is also known as Occam's razor, parsimony, and model efficiency. Q: How do we measure the 'explaining power'? A: There are many ways, but the best is to use statistical methods, including hypothesis testing. Examples of statistics in science Suppose 100 pills given to a random sample of people, of which 50 are placebos. Suppose all those taking the pill are dead by the next day, but none of those taking the placebo are dead. Conclusion: the pill is deadly. The hypothesis “The pill is deadly” is made a posteriori
Read more

Holliday et al.'s (2023) Gish Gallop: timing of the Younger-Dryas onset and Greenland platinum spike

Image
The location of several Greenland ice cores, from Steffensen et al. (2008). Over the next few months/year I'll post a regular series of blog posts that deconstruct Holliday et al.'s (2023) (henceforth, just Holliday et al.) "comprehensive refutation" of the YDIH. Some common themes will become apparent. Essentially, there are no refutation arguments at all in it, so their title is misleading. Remember, the meaning of 'refute' is to 'disprove', but there are no arguments in Holliday et al. that disprove the YDIH. It's also worth looking up the  'Gish gallop' fallacy, because that is what is happening here. Holliday et al.'s paper might be extremely long, but it is lacking in serious arguments, and there are certainly no refutations. First up in this blog post is the timing of the YD climate change (specifically its onset) and the Greenland platinum spike. The relevant sections of Holliday et al. are 3.3 and 5.1. My comments are in itali
Read more

Gobekli Tepe's Pillars

Image
Significance: Gobekli Tepe (GT) probably represents the origin of civilisation for most of the world today. Most of us are connected to it in some way, through language and religion (proto-Nostratic), or genetics at least. The Pillars: GT is famous for its anomalous megalithic pillars, and especially the symbols carved on them. Most people think these symbols are telling an important story - they are not just random pictures of animals. Klauss Schmidt, who discovered GT and led its excavation, until his death in 2014, certainly thought so. It follows that the only way we will ever be able to properly understand Gobekli Tepe, and therefore the origin of civilisation, is through reading its pillars. Deutsche Archaeological Institute : the DAI operates the Gobekli Tepe dig. Despite the immense significance of the site, they continue to have a casual disregard for the information encoded on its pillars. Over 60 pillars have been uncovered, but only around 20 are documented by the DAI. Alt
Read more